top of page

The 4 reasons I couldn't enjoy Bridgerton on Netflix

Based on the series of novels by Julia Quinn, Bridgerton, created by Chris Van Dusen, is the first Shondaland series to debut under the Netflix development deal Shonda Rhimes signed in 2017.

Warning: This post contains spoilers

Trigger Warning: This post contains content about sexual assault

Photo Courtesy: Twitter/@bridgerton

When I heard a period piece featuring Black people was coming to Netflix, I was pretty excited. It's a show primarily focused on the young women of society in London who participate in the social season, which is essentially the marriage market where various suitors attempt to become their husbands. The central character is the eldest daughter of the Bridgerton family, Daphne (Phoebe Dynevor), who falls for the Duke of Hastings, Simon Bassett (Regé-Jene Page).

After watching how diverse the trailer was, I thought this might finally be our chance to see young Black women as members of society in a period drama taking part in the social season being courted and desired. Unfortunately, I was let down for a few reasons:

1. The only Black girl, Marina (Ruby Barker), who is young enough to be courted and could even catch the eye of most of the potential suitors, is pregnant by the end of episode 1. We get about 20 minutes of her being one of the most desired at court before that's shot to hell. She's then locked away, forced later to rejoin the social season to find a man to take care of her and her unborn child, and finally, we find that the man who impregnated her did love her and would've given her a great life, but of course, he's dead now. Her storyline is just...awful.

2. While Black girls were shown to be apart of society, they were mostly just background characters. They were used to fulfill the "diversity" aesthetic the show wanted to create without giving younger women of color a story worth paying attention to. For a show touted for its blind casting in its promotion, the show is still overwhelmingly white, and the White leading lady is regarded as a "diamond" that's protected by the men, which wouldn't be so bad until you compare how the one Black girl is treated.

3. The show has a colorism problem. Simon's dark skin father is ruthless to his own son and ignores his wife while she bleeds out after giving birth. In typical Netflix fashion, the only other Black women besides Marina who are apart of the main cast are the Queen and the surrogate mother of the Duke, Lady Danbury. Lady Danbury is the only dark skin Black woman who is apart of the cast at all. This brings me to a problem I have with Netflix in general:

4. Daphne rapes her husband, Simon, and the scene is written to sympathize with Daphne. I was taken aback by how the show handled it's own rape scene so poorly when Daphne punched a man who tried to force himself on her earlier in the show.

Yet, several episodes later, when Daphne learns Simon is using the pull-out method to avoid giving her children, Daphne then forces herself on top of him and refuses to get off even though Simon wants her to so that he'll be forced to ejaculate in her. This is rape. The scene is written to make Daphne seem justified and Simon the villain for lying about his ability to have kids. While Simon may be wrong for lying, it will never justify Daphne refusing to get off of him, and the show handles it poorly.


bottom of page